Submit a Story!
topics:

Audience Participation: Why Don’t Readers Comment On Fiction?
We get a lot of comments on our non-fiction but hardly any on our fiction, and we're not alone. We're wondering what prompts or prohibits readers from commenting on fiction online in the forums or comments sections provided by the magazines.
2 Comments
  • MalloryCA MalloryCA
    +1

    This ties in nicely with one of my complaints - I want editors to include feedback opportunities for my readers and they are always surprised by this. If it's an online venue this should be a no-brainer (to me) but generally there isn't even an email link at the end of a piece.

     

    Basically, for people who read my message board or blog and then follow a link to one of my stories - I request that they email the venue with a comment or feedback once they have read it. I don't care what they say (good or bad) - I simply like that they are invited to participate in the story - the life of the story.

     

    Editors who have received some of these emails seem to be both surprised and to have fun with them too.

     

    Posted 11/26/2008 respond (flag)
    • EmilyBlips EmilyBlips
      +1
      Yeah, I guess I like having the option to comment on stories. Even if all I want to do is say, "Wow, this was really good," or something equally inane.
      Posted 11/26/2008 respond (flag)
Blog Reactions

SF Tidbits for 11/26/08
SF Signal — ... architecture, design, movie SF and art. [via Futurismic via Ken MacLeod] TheForce.Net notes the option of purchasing a personalized edition Star Wars: Millennium Falcon by James Luceno. Customization includes a personalized photo and printed dedication. Andrew Wheeler knows what authors really mean when they talk about genre boundaries. Fantasy Magazine asks: Why Don't Readers Comment On Fiction? Peggy at Biology in Science Fiction is compiling ...

November 27, 2008 Links and Plugs
Bibliophile Stalker — ... this.) SF Signal's latest Mind Meld asks Who are the Most Memorable Characters in the various genres. Can you guess who mine was? (Answers at the link.) Here's a nifty program for all you writers/editors who sends out their manuscripts to various editors and/or alpha/beta readers: TextFlow. Basically it tracks down the changes in various documents. See the video for a demo. Fantasy Magazine has two interesting articles up: Why Don't Readers Comment on Fiction? and Ten Things You Should Know About Twilight. ...

Related Content
First Readers
deanwesleysmith.com 10/4/2008 — I had a good question on how you find a first reader, and what is the difference between a first reader and a workshop. First it would be important to understand what a first reader does, so let me start there. -- A first reader reads your story ...